Is A Crate And Barrel Sofa Good Quality? (The Positives & The Negatives) 

Last Updated on September 25, 2022 by

Crate and Barrel sofas are of good quality based on online reviews. They are made of good material, joints, upholstery, suspension, and cushion filling. However, the brand’s furniture has a higher price tag which many say doesn’t go with the quality. Simply, the sofas are good but not great as per the cost. 

Purchasing a couch is not a small task, and you will have to consider many factors before picking out the best sofa. Apart from the price, needs, and space, you will have to pick your furniture from a reputable brand for quality assurance. Crate and Barrel is one of the leading stores selling sofas in the US. But, despite being one of the best, many customers have questioned their quality based on their higher price tag.

The assumption has always been the most expensive furniture has better quality. But, this has not always been the case with Crate and Barrel sofas. Despite spending so much money on the brand’s sofas, some customers have been disappointed. Others are satisfied with the quality of the sofas.

So, many are left asking; is a Crate and Barrel sofa good quality?

This article looks at the positives and negatives of the Crate and Barrel sofa based on customer reviews. 

Read on for wise decision-making!

The Quality Of Crate And Barrel Couches

The Quality Of Crate And Barrel Couches

Crate and Barrel rarely have bad sofas in their catalog. It is safe to say that they have done a pretty good job with their couches compared to other brands in the market. 

Their sofas are made in America North Carolina, and are mostly known for their very good quality. The Lounge II, Axis II, Gather, and Petrie are among the few ones made in North Carolina.

Their premium sofas are made of kiln-dried hardwood frames, joints screwed in, and glued and high-quality cushions, which all indicate good quality.

Due to the brand’s quality, the couches rarely sag and always maintain the standards that the company lives for. 

Another advantage of their sofa is that they can be revived or replaced and made new when the external areas get torn and worn out.

Why Purchase A Sofa From Crate And Barrel? (the Positives)

Despite the negatives, some reasons make Crate and Barrel a good store to consider when buying sofas. 

Some of the reasons are:

1. Durability

Sofas from Crate and Barrel are manufactured from hardwood. This type of wood is strong and does not get damaged easily. Reviews on their couches are full of praises on how well the sofas hold up even under extreme conditions that could break other couches.

2. Comfort

A sofa should be comfortable enough to make it easy for you to rest without straining or later experiencing pains and aches. The cushions used to make the sofas are deeper and comfier than other common couches.

3. Maintains Its Frame

Sofas have dens to sag and may lose shape as you continue using them. Crate and barrel sofas are made so that the couch maintains its original condition for many years without developing any clumps or even sagging.

4. Good Fabric Material

If you have kids and pets around your homes, getting a couch made with good durable, and stain-free material is indispensable. All sorts of spills or bodily fluids can cause permanent stains when it gets on the sofa.

Therefore, it is best to buy a sofa made of easily cleaned material which does not hold stains. Crate and Barrel sofas are made so that you can remove the covers, clean them, and then put them back on the couch. Other couches in the market will most likely not have such covers, and once you stain, it isn’t easy to clean. 

It might force you to purchase a new couch or call professionals to do a deep cleaning to remove the stain.

How To Clean A Crate And Barrel Sofa

1. Remove the cushion covers and toss them in the washing machine. Do this cleaning for big messes that you cannot fix with baby wipes.

2. Use a paper towel or baby wipes for small spills.

How To Clean A Crate And Barrel Sofa

Why Should You Not Buy A Crate And Barrel Sofa? (the Negatives) 

Crate and Barrel is a great store to purchase your sofa, but they fall short in some areas when it comes to it their sofas.

The main concerns include: 

1. The Price

As per the prices set up for couches in the market, Crate and Barrel prices seem higher than most stores. Many people will go to IKEA for cheaper furniture than shop at Crate and Barrel.

However, an item being too expensive is an opinion that changes depending on your budget. For people with exceptional financial muscle, Crate and Barrel prices might seem like the ideal pricing, but it can be a bit too much for others.

On average, the common couches at Crate and Barrel range from 1,800 dollars to 2000 dollars minimum. There are other sofas in their shops that are way more costly.

To be clear, these are not the exact prices of these models at Crate and Barrel; they are base and estimated costs. The price tag can increase or decrease depending on the size of the furniture you select. The minimum amount you can get a leather couch from Crate and Barrel is 2,500 dollars.

When you compare these prices to what you can get from IKEA, they come off as too high and may not be worth it.

2. Credibility And Reviews

The buying process is never as easy as picking a couch, paying, and going home. You have to consider customer service, reputation, and post-sales support. Check the online reviews from verified customers before making a purchase.

Unlike in the past, where Crate and Barrel had great reviews and their reputation was solid, recently, it has lost its credibility due to negative reviews. It has continued receiving bad reviews, proving that the quality of service and products has gone down over the years.

How To Purchase A Good Quality Couch

Buying a good-quality sofa is not an easy thing to do. There are various things you need to consider; how you will use the couch, the space it will occupy, and the style of the room you have. 

The following pointers can help you make a better decision when you go to any store, including Crate and Barrel, to get a couch.

How To Purchase A Good Quality Couch

1. The Material

Regardless of your choice of furniture store, you should always select a sofa made of the best fabric. This ensures your couch does not stain or start getting worn out after a month.

If you have children and pets around, pick a couch with an easy-to-clean material. This lowers the maintenance cost of the fabric and keeps the sofa in the best condition. Textured fabrics are the best for areas with high activity and high chances of getting spills and stains. Such materials do not show wear and tear easily. High-maintenance fabrics like silk should be avoided or only purchased for rooms less frequented by kids or pets.

2. Stuffing Fabric

Stuffing is another part that you should not overlook. Most people prefer an overstuffed sofa as it increases comfort and ensures you do not feel the couch’s frame. Polyurethane foam is one of the materials used to make cushions; it is firm and long-lasting.

However, the cushion made from polyurethane may be a little too hard, which takes time to break them in and make them soft. Consider better cushion materials available that are not as hard but are as long-lasting as the polyurethane ones.

3. Frame

The frame on your sofa is the one part that should not be of cheap and brittle material. A hardwood frame is the best and most trusted in the furniture industry. It is long-lasting and will not succumb to pressure.

4. Other Features

Technology has advanced so much in recent years, even with sofas and other furniture. It would help if you looked at extra features like cup holders, charging ports, reclining, replaceable covers, and storage compartment. There is no need to buy a basic sofa when you can get a better, easier to use, and more comfortable one.

Always consider what you need or would require in the future from your sofa to pick out a couch that will serve you best. 

5. Size And Space

Sofas should fit the space you have. So, pick the right size depending on how you want to use the couch and the room available. 

Final Thoughts

Crate and Barrel have great sofas for sale, they use good material, and above all else, they have replaceable covers. The sofas might be a bit expensive compared to other stores, but the price of a quality object cannot be the same as any other common item. Even though Crate and Barrel have had a few bad reviews, this does not mean that the quality of the product is low. Check the online reviews and consider personal preference, finances, and other factors to decide whether to purchase a sofa from Crate and Barrel.


Leave a Comment